OpticVerdict Independent buying guides
Search OpticVerdict

Streamlight vs SureFire (and Olight): which weapon light brand fits you?

By the OpticVerdict Editorial Team.
Research-based comparison · Updated 2026-11-05

Our verdict: the three brands differ more in how they build, power and warrant their lights than in raw lumens. SureFire says its WeaponLights are “designed, machined, tested, and assembled in the U.S.”, and its pistol lights in our pairs run on 123A lithium cells, two of them (the XC3-B and XC3 Sub) also on SureFire’s own SFRCR123 rechargeable. Streamlight prints “Assembled in the USA” on its TLR pistol light pages, and its compact pistol lights in our pairs take either its USB-C rechargeable pack or a CR123A. On the same cell type, Streamlight’s own candela figures match or beat SureFire’s in the full-size and compact pistol pairs, while SureFire’s high candela pistol light in these pairs is rated at 66,000 candela, above every Streamlight pistol light here. Olight leans on rechargeable cells, several of them built in, and its US warranty page covers lights and built-in batteries for life on purchases after 2023.

SureFire and Streamlight both give rechargeable batteries and chargers two years rather than life, and Streamlight adds switches and electronics to that two-year list. Neither SureFire nor Streamlight prints a drop height for the pistol lights we read. Choose the exact model that fits your gun and your holster first (our pistol light picks and rifle light picks list them model by model); the brand comes second.

See the Streamlight TLR-1 HL on OpticsPlanet

How we researched this: a research-based comparison built from the makers’ own product pages, fact sheets, manuals and warranty pages, the wording of the ANSI/PLATO FL1 flashlight standard, independent measured tests by the review site 1Lumen (one each of the Olight Odin S, Olight PL X and Streamlight TLR-7 HL-X), a Health Canada recall record and holster makers’ own statements and fit charts. We have not tested these lights ourselves. Prices come from the retailer’s product pages; confirm the current price and availability on the retailer page. See how we evaluate.

Model pairs: SureFire vs Streamlight vs Olight on maker figures

SureFire and Streamlight figures come from their own product pages and fact sheets. Olight’s candela, weight and water figures come from a comparison table on Olight’s own blog, which does not state its test method.

ClassSureFireStreamlightOlight
Full-size pistol X300U-A Ultra
1,000 lm, 11,300 cd on two 123A
3.76 in long, 4.0 oz with batteries
IPX7 (1 m, 30 min)
around $320
TLR-1 HL
1,000 lm, 20,000 cd on two CR123A
3.39 in long, 4.32 oz with batteries
IPX7
around $180
PL-3R Valkyrie
1,500 lm, 10,200 cd
3.19 in long, 3.77 oz with battery
Built-in rechargeable
IPX6
Compact pistol, rechargeable XC3-B
1,000 lm, 13,000 cd, 0.75 h on the included SFRCR123 rechargeable
550 lm, 7,200 cd, 1.75 h on a 123A
2.6 in long, 2.65 oz with battery
IPX7
TLR-7 HL-X USB
1,100 lm, 23,000 cd, 30 min (default) on SL-B9 rechargeable
550 lm, 11,000 cd, 1.5 h on a CR123A
2.90 in long, 2.88 oz with SL-B9
IPX7 (1 m, 30 min)
around $190
Baldr S (light and laser)
300 to 800 lm on high, 4,400 cd
2.48 in long, 3.35 oz
Built-in lithium polymer
IPX4
around $130
Compact pistol, one CR123A XC3-A
550 lm, 7,200 cd, 1.75 h on one 123A
2.6 in long, 2.65 oz with battery
Water rating: not on its spec sheet
TLR-7 X
550 lm, 7,200 cd, 1.5 h on a CR123A
725 lm, 9,500 cd, 1 h with no battery named in its spec row
Also takes an SL-B9 pack
2.58 in long, 2.48 oz with CR123A
IPX7 (1 m, 30 min)
PL-Mini 2 Valkyrie
600 lm, 2,500 cd
Rechargeable
Weight: Not in the maker pages we read
Water rating: Not in the maker pages we read
Subcompact pistol XC3 Sub
1,000 lm, 13,000 cd on the included SFRCR123
550 lm on a 123A
2.6 in long, 2.65 oz with battery
IPX7
Rail sets listed for Glock 43X/48, Springfield Hellcat, H&K CC9 and SIG P365
TLR-7 HL-X sub
1,000 lm, 13,000 cd, 30 min (default) on SL-B9
550 lm, 7,300 cd, 1.5 h on a CR123A
2.51 in long, 2.49 oz with SL-B9
IPX7
Fits select subcompact handguns, with a separate fact sheet per version
No subcompact-only Olight model in our reading; Olight lists its P365 Rail Mount and 43X MOS Mount for the PL-Mini 2 and Baldr S
Rifle M600U Scout Light
1,000 lm, 11,300 cd on two 123A
5.5 in long, 4.8 oz with batteries
IPX7
ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro
1,000 lm, 50,000 cd
Two CR123A or one SL-B26 rechargeable
6.6 oz with CR123A, 7.2 oz with SL-B26
IP67 with the push-button switch, IP54 with the remote switch
around $170
Odin S
1,500 lm on the included 18650, 15,600 cd
1,000 lm on high with two CR123A
5.02 in long, 6.81 oz with battery
IPX8
around $150
High candela pistol X300T Turbo
650 lm, 66,000 cd on two 123A
4.4 oz with batteries
IPX7 (1 m, 30 min)
around $310
No Streamlight pistol light in these pairs matches it; the highest Streamlight maker figure for a pistol light here is the TLR-7 HL-X USB’s 23,000 cd PL X (dual beam)
1,200 lm flood, 22,500 cd spot
IPX7, drops up to 1.5 m
USB-C charging
Battery and weight: Not in the maker pages we read
Check the SureFire X300U-A price Check the Olight Odin S price Check the SureFire X300T-A Turbo price

Streamlight’s TLR-7 X page gives two sets of figures. Its specification table lists 550 lumens and 7,200 candela on a CR123A, and a second spec row lists 725 lumens, 9,500 candela and a 1-hour run time without naming a battery. Its feature list, printed on the TLR-7 X page and again at Streamlight’s TLR-7A web address, reads “725 lumens; 9,500 candela; 195m beam; runs 1.5 hours (CR123A), runs 1 hour (SL-B9)”. The 500 lumens and 5,000 candela that some comparisons give the TLR-7 X come from Streamlight’s 2019 launch release for the older TLR-7A.

SureFire publishes spec sheets for two XC3 versions. The XC3-A runs on one 123A and is rated at 550 lumens and 7,200 candela, the same as the TLR-7 X’s CR123A row. The XC3-B ships with SureFire’s SFRCR123, a protected 3.6-volt RCR123 lithium-ion cell of 900 mAh, and reaches 1,000 lumens and 13,000 candela only on that cell; its manual gives 550 lumens and 7,200 candela on a 123A. SureFire’s spec sheet says the XC3-B delivers “nearly double the lumens and candela of the original XC3”. An archived copy of SureFire’s XC3 page from January 29, 2025, with no -A or -B in the name, lists 550 lumens, 7,200 candela and one included SF123A. No SureFire source we read gives the XC3 7,500 candela, a figure some comparisons print.

SureFire’s smaller XSC-A, 1.94 in long and made for Glock 43X and 48 pistols with Glock’s slim rail, runs on a proprietary rechargeable battery at 350 lumens and 2,000 candela, rated IPX4.

The Baldr S pairs its light with a laser. Streamlight’s TLR-8 models do the same: its info sheet rates the TLR-8 A’s white LED at 500 lumens and 5,000 candela on one CR123A. Streamlight’s 2020 launch release gives the TLR-8 A a 640 to 660 nm red laser and the TLR-8 A G a 510 to 520 nm green laser, while its TLR-7/TLR-8 operating instructions print Class 3R notices for 640 to 660 nm and 510 to 530 nm lasers under 5 mW.

Streamlight’s own documents disagree on the TLR-7 HL-X. The current product page and fact sheet #411 give 1,100 lumens and 23,000 candela on the SL-B9 pack, and 550 lumens and 11,000 candela on a CR123A. The May 2024 launch release said up to 1,000 lumens and 22,000 candela. The operating instructions it shares with the TLR-8 HL-X say the pack can be programmed to 1,000 lumens for up to 30 minutes or 500 lumens for up to 1 hour, and that the light runs at 500 lumens on a CR123A.

Weights also vary by version. SureFire gives 4.0 oz for the X300U-A and 4.1 oz for the T-slot X300U-B, and Streamlight’s fact sheet #259 gives 4.32 oz for the TLR-1 HL with batteries. The 4.18 oz some sites print for the TLR-1 HL is not in Streamlight’s sources we read.

Where SureFire, Streamlight and Olight lights are made

SureFire says its work began in 1979 with laser technology, under founder Dr. John Matthews; Streamlight dates its founding to 1973. SureFire says its flashlights and WeaponLights are “designed, machined, tested, and assembled in the U.S.”, at its facilities in Fountain Valley, California. It does not mark them Made in the U.S.A., because it imports a few components, the LEDs among them. SureFire adds that “every SureFire product meets the criteria of the Buy American Act”.

Streamlight varies by product, so check the model. The TLR-7 HL-X, TLR-7 X and TLR-7 HL-X sub product pages say “Assembled in the USA”, and fact sheet #259 for the TLR-1 HL says “Assembled in the U.S.A.” Fact sheet #413 for the TLR-1 HL-X says “Assembled in the USA of US and Foreign Parts”. Fact sheet #398 for the ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro rifle light says “Made in China”, as does fact sheet #321 for the ProTac HL 5-X handheld. Streamlight says its headquarters and manufacturing plant are in Eagleville, Pennsylvania.

Olight’s own about page says it built an independent large production base in 2017 but does not say where. Its US office is in Lorton, Virginia. One Olight manual, for a pocket flashlight rather than a weapon light, is printed “Made in China”. Editorial sources name two different Chinese cities for Olight’s factory, so we name none.

Warranty side by side

SureFireStreamlightOlight (US page)
The lightRepair or replace a defect in material or workmanship during your lifetimeLimited lifetime: free of defects for a lifetime of useLifetime on lights and rail-mounted lights
Rechargeable batteries2 years from purchase2 years with proof of purchaseLifetime on built-in batteries; batteries that fail from ordinary use or aging are excluded
Chargers, switches, electronicsChargers 2 yearsChargers, switches and electronics 2 yearsCharging cables 1 year; remote pressure switches and weapon mounts 1 year (Olight blog)
Main exclusionsConsumables, normal wear, abuse, alterations, unauthorized repairsBatteries and bulbs, abuse, normal wearLoss, theft, misuse, modifications, cosmetic wear, accidents
ConditionsNon-SureFire batteries other than Panasonic, Duracell or Energizer void itYour product may carry the warranty in place when you bought itPurchases after 2023 only; transferable

Olight’s terms depend on where you buy. The US lifetime warranty page was updated June 3, 2026 and says “Products purchased after 2023 are only eligible.” Olight’s Canada page sets a 5-year warranty for most flashlights and 2 years for built-in battery rail-mounted lights. The PL-3R’s own manual prints repair or replacement within 2 years of purchase and one year on the USB magnetic charging cable. Streamlight can also repair, replace or refund the purchase price; SureFire’s wording is repair or replace.

Batteries: CR123A, rechargeable packs and built-in cells

SureFire’s X300U-A, X300U-B, X300T and M600U Scout each take two 123A lithium cells. SureFire says a fully depleted SFRCR123 can take over 2.5 hours to charge through its USB-C port. SureFire’s M600DF rifle light ships with an SF18650B, a protected 3.6-volt 18650 of 3.5 Ah. SureFire rates it at 1,500 lumens, 16,000 candela and 1.5 hours on that cell, and at 1,200 lumens, 12,800 candela and 1.25 hours on two 123A. SureFire’s FAQ says genuine Panasonic, Duracell or Energizer cells keep the warranty, and any other non-SureFire brand voids it.

Changing the battery with the light on the gun depends on the model. SureFire says the XC3’s front-loading battery changes without removing the light from the host weapon, and its XC3 Sub spec sheet says the same. The XC3-B manual adds: “ALWAYS ensure firearm is unloaded and clear before changing the battery.” The X300 B-series manual opens the battery cover with a latch, and the Scout Light manual changes cells by unscrewing the LED head. Streamlight says the TLR-1 HL-X’s front-loading compartment allows battery replacement without removing the light from the firearm. Its TLR-7 HL-X manual changes the battery by unscrewing the face cap assembly and does not say the light must come off the gun.

Streamlight’s TLR-7 HL-X takes its SL-B9 USB-C pack or one CR123A. The pack charges within 2.5 hours and is rated for up to 500 cycles. Streamlight rates the light from -4°F to +120°F on the SL-B9 and from -40°F to +120°F on a CR123A. The TLR-1 HL runs on two CR123A. The ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro takes two CR123A or one SL-B26 pack, and its fact sheet gives the CR123A cells a storage life of 10 years.

Olight’s PL-3R manual lists a built-in 900mAh lithium polymer battery charged through a magnetic USB charger, and Olight says the light recharges without being removed from the weapon. Olight’s support page says a defective battery or charging cable can be bought new, or replaced by customer service within the warranty period; it does not say whether an owner can change the PL-3R’s built-in cell. The Baldr S has a built-in lithium polymer battery charged by Olight’s magnetic cable, and the PL X charges through USB-C. The Odin S takes a 3500mAh 18650 rechargeable or two CR123A, and Olight lists a lower high mode on CR123A: 1,000 lumens against 1,500 on the 18650.

Durability, water and impact ratings

Under the FL1 standard, an IPX4 icon means the light was sprayed with water from all angles, and an IPX7 icon means it was submerged at least 1 meter deep for 30 minutes. FL1 runs the water test after the impact test. Its impact rating needs six drops onto concrete from at least 1 meter. Following FL1 is voluntary, and makers may run the tests themselves.

The XC3-A spec sheet prints no water rating. SureFire rates the other weapon lights in our pairs IPX7, for example the X300U-A as “waterproof to 1 meter for 30 minutes”, without naming the test standard on that page. SureFire’s XC3-B spec sheet states: “All performance claims tested to ANSI/PLATO FL1-2019 Standard.” Streamlight rates the TLRs we read IPX7, except the TLR-8 HL-X and TLR-8 A at IPX4. Olight’s blog table gives IPX6 for the PL-3R, IPX8 for the Odin S and IPX4 for the Baldr S without naming a standard. The PL-3R manual also prints IPX6 and says its data are tested per ANSI/NEMA FL 1-2019 in Olight’s labs. Olight rates the PL X IPX7.

Drop heights are rare. Streamlight’s TLR-7 HL-X fact sheet says “Extensively live fire tested” but gives no height. The one Streamlight weapon light with a drop figure in our reading is the ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro rifle light: its current info sheet says “2-meter impact resistance tested”, while its 2023 fact sheet gives no height. Streamlight also prints drop figures for two handhelds: 2 m for the ProTac 2L-X and 1 meter for the ProTac HL 5-X. We found no SureFire drop figure, and none of the maker documents we read publishes a failure rate. Olight says the PL X is tested against drops of up to 1.5 meters and that the PL-3R withstands recoil forces of up to 50 joules. SureFire hard-anodizes its X300U-A aluminum body to Mil-Spec, and Streamlight machines the TLR-7 HL-X body from 6000 series aircraft aluminum.

Switches: push and toggle, paddles and pressure pads

The X300U-A uses an ambidextrous push and toggle switch. SureFire’s X300 B-series manual gives constant-on by rotating the toggle up or down, and off by rotating it the opposite way. The XC3-B manual gives momentary-on by pressing and holding either side of the tailcap toggle, and constant-on by a quick tap and release. The XC3 also has a disable feature against accidental activation in storage or travel. The M600DF’s Z68 tailcap gives momentary-on with a slight press and constant-on when pressed until it clicks. The XC3-B and X300 B-series manuals we read do not mention a strobe.

SureFire says the X300U-B accepts its optional DG and XT pressure-activated remote switches, and its ST07 tape switch fits WeaponLights with plug sockets, the X300 among them. Its UE tailcap and DS00 fit Scout Light WeaponLights. The XC3 page, spec sheet and manual we read mention no remote switch.

Streamlight’s TLR-7 HL-X and TLR-7 X have ambidextrous rear paddles with HIGH and LOW options. The TLR-7 HL-X manual, shared with the TLR-8 HL-X, says the LOW and HIGH tail switches are interchangeable with the push pin on the multi-tool. That light ships with its strobe disabled; tapping either switch very rapidly 9 times and holding on the 10th turns it on. For “safe” mode, the manual says to loosen the facecap approximately ¼ turn to the detent. The TLR-1 HL-X includes High and Extended High rear paddles.

The TLR-1 HL has an ambidextrous momentary or steady switch and ships with its strobe enabled. A double tap of the momentary paddle within 0.4 seconds starts the strobe, and ten very rapid taps, holding on the tenth, turn it off. Its remote switches must be used with Streamlight’s 69130 or 69161 remote door switch, and Streamlight does not recommend the strobe with a remote switch. The TLR-7 HL-X documents we read list no remote switch. The ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro has a push-button tail switch and a port for a remote pressure switch; its CR123A kit (item 88126) includes a Jack Cap, an M-LOK mount and a momentary switch. The standard ProTac Rail Mount HL-X comes with a remote pressure switch and a push-button tail cap switch, and its TEN-TAP programs are high/strobe, high only and low/high, with a 60-lumen low.

Olight’s Baldr S uses dual rear switches for momentary or constant-on and has a 100-lumen low mode rated for up to 140 minutes. The Odin S uses a magnetic pressure switch with a screw cap and has a 300-lumen low. The PL-3R accepts an optional magnetic remote pressure switch for long guns, has a 300-lumen second mode and strobes at 13 Hz. None of the maker documents we read gives a switch pressure figure.

Mounting and moving a light between guns

SureFire’s X300U-A attaches to Universal and Picatinny rails, and its Lever Latch system “permits rapid attachment to and removal from rails on pistols or rifles”. The X300U-B uses a T-slot thumbscrew clamp instead. The XC3-B ships with a Universal crossmember fitted and a Picatinny crossmember in the box. Its manual says some pistols with a MIL-STD-1913 rail may need the “U” crossmember, and gives a clamp torque of 8 in-lb on a polymer pistol rail and 8 to 9 in-lb on a metal one. SureFire’s Scout Light manual tightens the M600U’s M75 thumbscrew mount by hand, then another 1/4 turn with a flat tool.

Streamlight’s TLR-1 HL includes keys for Glock-style, Picatinny, Beretta 90two, S&W 99, S&W TSW and Sig P320 rails. The TLR-7 HL-X ships with a rail key installed and other keys included, and its manual warns: “A KEY MUST BE USED OR THE TLR WILL SLIDE OFF THE WEAPON RAIL UNDER RECOIL.” Changing the key means taking the light off the gun, and the clamp is tightened only finger tight. Streamlight’s TLR-7/TLR-8 compatibility list, revised July 15, 2026, gives key 1913-1 for most Gen 5 full-size and compact Glocks with rails and UNIV-1 for those up to Gen 4. The TLR-7 X uses a rail-grip clamp that attaches and detaches without putting your hands in front of the muzzle.

Olight’s Odin S comes in M-LOK and Picatinny editions. The Baldr S ships with a Glock insert installed and a Picatinny insert included. The PL-Mini 2’s adjustable sliding rail fits both GL and PIC rails, and Olight packs a 1913 adapter and Allen wrenches with the PL-3R.

Holster fit: SureFire XC3, TLR-7 and X300

SureFire says the XC3 “fits in a wide variety of holsters already on the market” but names no holster. Holster maker Four Brothers writes that “the XC3 does not seat properly in our TLR-7 X holsters” and tells XC3 owners to pick a holster molded for the XC3. KSG Armory reports that many people say it fits TLR-7 holsters and that KSG has not verified it. Safariland’s fit chart for duty and tactical holsters, revised March 22, 2024, lists the Streamlight TLR-7 with SureFire’s XC-1 and XC-2 and does not list the XC3. There is no universal answer, so buy a holster molded for the exact light.

Between the full-size lights, the same Safariland chart lists the Streamlight TLR-1 and TLR-1HL and the SureFire X300 or X300U together on the same row, for example its APX 9mm row. Dara Holsters wrote on October 30, 2024 that the HL-X models are not compatible with its molds for the original TLR-1 and TLR-7. Safariland’s chart names one Olight light, the PL-Pro Valkyrie. Olight’s PL X page says compatible carry accessories are available from multiple manufacturers without naming them, and the Olight pages we read name no holster brand for the Baldr S.

Within each brand the footprint changes too. KSG treats the TLR-7, TLR-7A and TLR-7X as one holster fit, but says the TLR-7 HL-X will not fit its holsters unless the holster names the HL-X, and that the TLR-1 HL-X is dimensionally different from the TLR-1 and TLR-1 HL. KSG fits the X300, X300U-A, X300U-B, X300T-A and X300T-B in the same holsters. Streamlight says the TLR-1 HL fits most existing light bearing holsters, and that a proper holster should fully cover the trigger guard area. Olight names holster brands for the PL-Mini 2, among them Alien Gear and Crossbreed.

Lumens vs candela: why the comparisons argue about candela

The FL1 standard measures light output as total lumens and peak beam intensity as the maximum intensity along the center of the beam, in candela. Beam distance follows from candela: it is the distance at which the beam falls to 0.25 lux, the square root of candela divided by 0.25. Streamlight’s 20,000 candela for the TLR-1 HL works out to about 283 meters, the beam distance on its fact sheet. SureFire’s 11,300 candela for the X300U-A works out to about 213 meters, the distance on SureFire’s page. Our reading, not a maker claim: at equal lumens, a higher candela figure means more of the light is packed into the center of the beam. SureFire describes the XC3-B’s parabolic reflector as giving “a focused hot spot” with “an optimized corona of diffused light” for the near field; its archived January 2025 XC3 page described a “Hybrid beam pattern”.

Runtime has a definition too. FL1 counts from 30 seconds after switch-on until output falls to 10% of the first reading. Streamlight gives the TLR-1 HL 1 hour of regulated runtime and 1.5 hours to 10%; the SureFire pages we read print a HIGH RUNTIME of 1.25 hours for the X300U-A without saying where the count stops. The TLR-7 HL-X runtimes in the table count “continuous operation to 10% output level”.

One independent measurement covers the TLR-7 HL-X. 1Lumen’s December 2024 review, using a 50 cm homemade integrating sphere and reading at 30 seconds as FL1 specifies, measured 1,122 lumens and 25,100 candela against the 1,000 lumens and 22,000 candela it lists as specified. In its FL1 runtime test on the included SL-B9, the 1,000-lumen mode ran 38 minutes against a specified 30. A 2025 edition of FL1, published in 2026 according to holster maker Safariland, expands and clarifies the FL1 metrics, especially for short turbo modes.

Olight: what its own pages say

Olight was founded in 2007 and launched its first rail-mounted light, the PL-1, in 2015. Its US lifetime warranty needs no paperwork.

Olight publishes its own step-down. Its table gives the PL-3R’s top mode as 1,500 lumens for 2 minutes, then 600 lumens for 36 minutes, then 300 lumens. For the Odin S on its included battery it lists 1,500, then 650, then 300 lumens. 1Lumen tested an Odin S on high with the included 18650. In a homemade lumen tube with a VEML7700 sensor it read 1,505 lumens at 30 seconds and 646 lumens at 10 minutes; from lux measured with a UNI-T UT383 BT at 5 meters it lists 16,300 candela against Olight’s 15,600.

1Lumen’s July 2026 review of the PL X, again a single measurement in a 50 cm integrating sphere, read 1,048 lumens from the floodlight at 30 seconds against Olight’s 1,200, and 874 lumens from the spotlight. It measured 24,448 candela from the spotlight against Olight’s 22,500. It lists a built-in 960 mAh lithium polymer battery and 87 g with battery.

Health Canada’s recall RA-64179, dated May 24, 2022, covers Olight’s M2R Pro and Warrior Mini flashlights, which “can be turned on inadvertently under unlock mode and overheat while stored in the holster or a consumer’s pocket, posing a burn hazard to consumers.” Olight says it recalled them in the United States in cooperation with the CPSC and that the recall “does not affect any other Olight products”. None of the Olight weapon lights compared here is named in that record.

Handheld flashlights from the same makers

SureFire rates the G2X Pro at 600 lumens and 8,700 candela on two 123A, at 4.4 oz with batteries and IPX7. Streamlight rates the ProTac 2L-X handheld at 500 lumens on high, IPX7 and 2 m impact tested.

Which brand should you buy?

Compact carry: see the Streamlight TLR-7 HL-X USB Rifle: see the Streamlight ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro

Where to look next

If you wantWhyWhere to look next
A full-size or compact pistol lightStreamlight, SureFire and Holosun pistol lights compared on maker figures.Pistol light picks
A light for an AR-15 or carbineRifle lights from Streamlight, Cloud Defensive, SureFire and Olight.Rifle light picks
The SureFire X300 in detailX300U-A, X300U-B and X300T-A Turbo, mounting and warranty.SureFire X300 Ultra review
The Streamlight TLR-1 HL in detailOutput, runtime, rail keys and holster fit.Streamlight TLR-1 HL review
A Streamlight rifle lightThe ProTac Rail Mount HL-X and its Pro kit.ProTac Rail Mount HL-X review
A pistol light with a laserSureFire’s Turbo head with a red or green laser.SureFire X400 Turbo review
A handheld SureFireThe G2X on two 123A cells.SureFire G2X review
A handheld tactical flashlightHandhelds from several makers side by side.Tactical flashlight picks
Spare cells for a 123A lightCR123 and CR123A cells, and the rechargeable cells that differ.CR123 vs CR123A

FAQ

Is SureFire better than Streamlight?

The makers’ own figures do not make either brand better across the board. In the full-size pair, Streamlight rates the TLR-1 HL at 20,000 candela and SureFire rates the X300U-A at 11,300, both at 1,000 lumens on two lithium 123A cells. SureFire says its WeaponLights are designed, machined, tested and assembled in the U.S.; Streamlight’s TLR pages say Assembled in the USA. Both rate these lights IPX7 and back them with lifetime warranties that carry exclusions.

Is Streamlight made in the USA?

It depends on the product. Streamlight’s TLR product pages and the TLR-1 HL fact sheet say Assembled in the USA, and the TLR-1 HL-X fact sheet says Assembled in the USA of US and Foreign Parts. Streamlight’s fact sheets for the ProTac Rail Mount HL-X Pro rifle light and the ProTac HL 5-X handheld say Made in China. Streamlight says its headquarters and manufacturing plant are in Eagleville, Pennsylvania.

Is Olight as good as Streamlight?

No maker figure settles it. Olight’s US warranty page covers its lights and built-in batteries for life on purchases after 2023; Streamlight gives a limited lifetime warranty with two years on rechargeable batteries, chargers, switches and electronics. In single independent tests by 1Lumen, an Odin S read 1,505 lumens at 30 seconds against Olight’s 1,500, and a PL X floodlight read 1,048 lumens against Olight’s 1,200.

Does the SureFire XC3 fit TLR-7 holsters?

Not reliably. SureFire says the XC3 fits a wide variety of holsters already on the market, but it names no holster. Holster maker Four Brothers says the XC3 does not seat properly in its TLR-7 X holsters. KSG Armory says many people claim it fits TLR-7 holsters, but KSG has not verified it. Safariland’s fit chart, revised March 22, 2024, lists the TLR-7 with SureFire’s XC-1 and XC-2, not the XC3. Buy a holster molded for the exact light.

Which weapon light has the longest warranty?

All three brands cover the light itself for life, with different exclusions. SureFire repairs or replaces defects in material or workmanship during your lifetime and gives rechargeable batteries and chargers two years. Streamlight’s limited lifetime warranty gives rechargeable batteries, chargers, switches and electronics two years. Olight’s US page covers lights and built-in batteries for life on purchases after 2023, while its Canada page gives built-in battery rail lights two years.

Does the SureFire XC3 run on a rechargeable battery?

It depends on the version. SureFire’s XC3-A runs on one 123A lithium cell and is rated at 550 lumens and 7,200 candela. The XC3-B ships with SureFire’s SFRCR123, a 3.6-volt rechargeable lithium-ion RCR123 cell, and is rated at 1,000 lumens and 13,000 candela on it, or 550 lumens and 7,200 candela on a 123A. An archived copy of SureFire’s XC3 page from January 29, 2025 lists 550 lumens on one included SF123A.

Can you change the battery without taking the light off the gun?

On some models. SureFire says the XC3 and XC3 Sub load from the front, so the battery changes without removing the light from the host weapon, and the XC3-B manual says to make sure the firearm is unloaded and clear first. Streamlight says the same of the TLR-1 HL-X’s front-loading battery compartment. Olight says the PL-3R recharges without being removed from the weapon.

Has Olight recalled any lights for overheating?

Yes. Health Canada’s recall RA-64179, dated May 24, 2022, covers Olight’s M2R Pro and Warrior Mini flashlights, which can turn on inadvertently in unlock mode and overheat in a holster or pocket, a burn hazard. Olight says it also recalled them in the United States with the CPSC and that no other Olight products are affected. That is the one recall record we read, not a full list. None of the weapon lights compared here is named in it.

OpticVerdict Editorial Team · research-based buying guides

Every award, spec and superlative in this guide is checked against a primary source before it is published, and every rating we cite is shown attributed to where it comes from. Read how we evaluate or learn more about this site.

Source-verified claims Attributed ratings only Method disclosed on every page